So we have automatic translation enabled on this website. And if i look in hidden link for a given media file (example "Salvus-Rome-Mini-1-elo-open-vol") it shows as translated (duplicated). It shows the same title as the original, wich is perfect.
But when we open up the ATE for the product where this media is used (hidden link) it shows as not translated and it wants me to "autotranslate" and this will cost credits. We don't want this. We just want the duplicated title wich also show in the Media Translation section.
You say "From that point on", but what about existing media that shows up in the ATE?
I ask this because we tried this already, and it still showed the media in the ATE having supposedly no translations, but they did have the min the Media Translation.
Languages: English (English )Spanish (Español )German (Deutsch )
Timezone: America/Lima (GMT-05:00)
If you exclude media from translation on the Advanced Translation Editor by going to WPML > Settings > Media Translation, then no media should appear any longer inside the Advanced Translation Editor.
On existing translation, you would only see the change after you made a change to the original content, which updates the translation status.
Languages: English (English )Spanish (Español )German (Deutsch )
Timezone: America/Lima (GMT-05:00)
Thank you, I absolutely understand your conerns, but would like to explain quick something.
Currently WPML has the following option at WPML > Settings > Media Translations:
- Automatically detect best options for translating image texts (alt, caption, title)
If this option is enabled the media, will show up inside the WPML Translation Editor and will only be translated, if assigned to a post. When translating the media inside the WPML Translation Editor, the translations rely on the translation memory of this editor, which runs on an external server and is controled by an external system.
You would basically use this new recommended method, to only translate media inside the WPML Translation Editor and this is the only way how you could translate the media automatically.
If you disable the option to automatically detect media, the media by default will not longer be exposed on the WPML Translation Editor and users can create the translations manually inside the WordPress media library or at WPML > Media Translation.
Now, you could still opt-in to display media inside the WPML Translation Editor without auto-detecting the media, but so far I can confirm that what is displayed inside the WPML Translation Editor differs from what has been translated manually outside of it.
This said, I would suggest for now sticking to only one of both workflows:
a) Translate media inside the WPML Translation Editor
or
b) Translate media manually outside of the WPML Translation Editor
If you mix both methods you will end up overwriting your manual translations inside the media library and at WPML > Media Translation.
I will be escalating this issue now internally for further revision and get back to you once I receive feedback.